The U.S. Marine Corps veteran also wounded seven people before a security officer shot and killed him. Smrekar and Drabing were both Manson followers, and the Schneider murders were considered a Manson copycat crime. Cold Cases Missing Persons Daily Archive. Get even more stories delivered right to your email. Interestingly, the T-shirt is the only item of evidence in the Martin case thats allegedly MISSING from the Lincoln PD, without explanation. Pike Co. cold case: 'Stuff's been covered up long enough' - FOX19 His alibi for the night of the Schneider murders was never fully corroborated. Kruegers lies have been exceptionally profound everything hes claimed about the T-shirt directly opposes established documented facts. Nevertheless, as the days passed authorities investigating the triple slaying at King Shoals, despite police holding Ellis McCoy in jail for open questioning, as well as Tom Ratliff of King Shoals, authorities remained baffled as to how and why the trio was killed. There was also other evidence that suggested Cindy met with foul play, in spite of no sign of forced entry. . Theres no doubt he was involved in the murders of Mansfield and Martin, but the facts and evidence in those cases support that he used accomplices. When McClouds friends hadnt seen her for a few days, they grew worried and went to her apartment at 4996 Chatterton Road. In light of Kruegers egregious lies and the importance of the details relating to the T-shirt, that evidence most assuredly did not disappear (if its really missing) by accident, and it also didnt sprout legs and walk out of the LPD on its own. They were indicted in 2003 and later pleaded guilty to child abuse charges. LOGAN Friday marked the 40th anniversary of a Logan murder that has long gone cold, but friends and family members of Gilbert "Andy" Anders Jr. are still holding out hope that the person. 1976 Logan County murders and probable cover-up Lincoln, IL realtor Ruth Louise Martin, 51, has been missing from her home since the morning of Wednesday, June 2, 1976. Neighbors who rushed to the home after hearing the shots found the four-year-old dead on the sofa and the baby also lying on the couch. Ohio city ranked second safest small city or town in U.S. 'The final straw;' Mikesell's . All Rights Reserved. unsolved murders in logan county ohio Cleveland.com has assembled a list of notorious figures from each of Ohio's 88 counties. Use of and/or registration on any portion of this site constitutes acceptance of our User Agreement, Privacy Policy and Cookie Statement, and Your Privacy Choices and Rights (each updated 1/26/2023). Drabing claimed he parked his car a mile to 2 miles from the Schneider residence and walked through fields to get to their house. The family usually took care to lock the doors because a couple of months earlier, Zastudil had discovered an intruder inside their home. Months later, on Oct. 9, 76, Jay Fry and his 3-months-pregnant wife, Robin, both 24, were shot-gunned to death in their home just 9 days prior to a scheduled hearing on the Kroger case. The Ohio Attorney Generals Office has created a new cold case unit to investigate unsolved crimes, and it is looking at several area cases of note. On September 18, 75, Smrekar stole 150 record albums and an expensive B.C. But Ohio's Third District Court of Appeals ruled earlier this year that she should receive a new trial because her conviction had been largely based on the boy's testimony, according to The Toledo Blade. The Berlin Reservoir killings: Two hunters in Deerfield County, Ohio came across a disturbing scene. Man indicted in 2000 Toledo murder and rape cold case Irwin said the Cold Case Unit is investigating the case at the request of Fairfield police. Donald Hoffman was sentenced to life in prison for the 2014 murders of four older men with health problems. Richey returned to prison in 2012 when, after moving to Mississippi, he drunkenly phoned and threatened a common pleas judge, according to The Toledo Blade. Bonnie J. Thompson, Investigative Writer/Author(Copyright 2013, 2015, 2017). The murders occurred in Belmont, Coshocton, Muskingum, Noble and Tuscarawas counties. 1 after John Dillinger's death in 1934. On Thursday, August 19, 76, wealthy Lincoln farmer Lloyd Schneider, his wife, Phyllis, and their daughter, Terri, 17, were murdered in their home stabbed a total of 90 TIMES. 46 Cause of Death. Detectives said Myers planned the murder and robbery. The previous year he lured a 9-year-old boy and his 7-year-old sister into the woods. Crime in Logan County, Ohio - Best Places The self-described angel of death claims he killed terminally ill or mortally injured patients to end their suffering from 1970 to 1987. Prior to the stabbings of Lloyd, Phyllis and Terri, two witnesses escaped through a bedroom window: the youngest Schneider daughter, 16, and Terri Schneiders boyfriend, 20. There is one other kicker to this story of unfortunate deaths in Logan County. James Litteral became the first Athens County convict to be executed in 1930. Gregory McKnight has been sentenced to death for the 2000 murder of Kenyon College student Emily Murray. Schlichters gambling addiction dogged him throughout his life and led to multiple stints in prison. We set out to identify and answer the question: "Who is the most notorious person from each county?" The Wellington resident claimed he had a video game addiction and that he had been playing the game 18 hours per day. On Thursday, August 19, 76, wealthy Lincoln farmer Lloyd Schneider, his wife, Phyllis, and their daughter, Terri, 17, were murdered in their home stabbed a total of 90 TIMES. CLEVELAND A couple from Canton has been desperate for answers after their elderly loved one was brutally murdered in a small Ohio town. I never heard Drabing or Jones say a word, but they were right beside Hanley, in Hanleys Chevy pickup, when the exchange took place. He is now serving a sentence of life in prison. The motive was a robbery to pay for cocaine, prosecutors said. He later became an investment banker and author. Cepec bludgeoned Munz with a hammer before he strangled him with a lamp cord, records show. Mastronardi and his insurance company also paid $3 million to Brabanders family, according to The Plain Dealer. Since Ruths remains have never been found, I have serious questions about the LPDs haste to close the Martin case, particularly when the Lincoln PD has suspiciously claimed the bloody T-shirt is missing and facts prove detectives have lied about it. Historians are divided as to whether Floyd participated in the Kansas City massacre that killed four law enforcement officers in 1933. Dahmer died in 1994 after a fellow inmate beat him to death in prison. And, while it took three years and some peculiar circumstances to resolve those murders, there has been one triple murder in Logan County that has never been solved. Then there is the 1930 murder of Logan Police Chief Roy Knotts, who was shot and killed on his first day on the job by Enoch Scaggs, a former Logan deputy and close ally of the Hatfield. Someone saw him doing it and reported him to the student activities director. After working a 48-hour shift at the hospital, the nurse anesthetist told her mother around 4 p.m. that she was going out for a jog. Fischer killed Abi Matthews at her Malta home in 2009. Six members of the Jeanette McAdams family mysteriously fell ill and died from 1848 to 1851. According to police, White had been living with Schoolcraft, who was found lying across the bed with one bullet hole in the left temple. Search for: View All Cold Cases. She disappeared 6 days before she was to testify against defendant Russell Albin Smrekar, 21, in a Lincoln grocery store shoplifting case. His trial is set for March 6, 2017. His alibi for the night of the Schneider murders was never fully corroborated. Winds SW at 5 to 10 mph. Morans rival Al Capone likely ordered the killings. Nine people died and 11 others were injured after Todd Hall tossed a lit cigarette into a fireworks store on July 3, 1996. He searched for the gun but couldnt find it. Anyone With A Heart Will Love The New Ohio Law That Just Went Into Effect, The 15 Downright Scariest Things To Ever Come Out Of Ohio, History Has Forgotten This Bizarre Ohio Event From 90 Years Ago. On November 6, 1993, hunters came across two deceased bodies. Daniel Petric was just 16 years old when he shot and killed his parents after they forbade him from playing Halo 3 on Oct. 20, 2007. There were/are manyanomalies in the Schneider case, too many to bring out in this writing, but Ill mention a few. who wins student body president riverdale. Gerald Hand remains on death row for the killing of his fourth wife Jill Hand and his friend Lonnie Welch in 2002. Smrekar was arrested and charged with Theft Under $150, and Fry became a key witness in the case. Unsolved murders that still haunt Northeast Ohio - WEWS More than a decade later, the case of who killed 37-year-old Michael Williams of Rogers remains open. Brutal unsolved killing of eight members of Ohio family was Following his conviction, Hanley and Jones pursued law degrees and became attorneys. Somehow, Drabing managed to return to his mothers house (where he also lived) within 10-15minutes of the killings, by 11:40 PM. The car showed signs of having been driven off the beaten track, and it was later learned that Ruth had the right front tire filled on June 1st because of a slow leak. Worley had already been charged with abducting the 20-year-old girl when officials found her body. It turned out to be Herbert, half-dressed, likely sexually assaulted and beaten to death. Dwight Williamson: Logan County history filled with unsolved murders Mrs. Whites survivors included her father, Jeff Jackson of Lundale; her mother, Mrs. Virginia Jackson; one sister, Miss Lorraine Jackson of Williamson; and two brothers, Herman Jackson of Lundale and Matt Jackson of Williamson. BOONE COUNTY, KY (WXIX) - One of Boone County's most horrific killings remains unsolved nearly 12 years later, but the detectives working the Stephenson case are leaving no stone unturned. That was a complete falsehood, for he wrote the report on that evidence and submitted the T-shirt to the Illinois State Crime Lab for testing. Cepec has appealed the death sentence to the Ohio Supreme Court. The shootout left three police officers and a civilian injured and ended in Roberts' death, according to The Associated Press. We won't share it with anyone else. Litteral killed and robbed a former World War I veteran the previous year. A few months later, in early March, a cunning cat burglar climbed a ladder to a second floor rear window of the Lincoln PD and stole the recovered B.C. Northeast Ohio's 50 Most Frustrating Cold Cases John Hedrick killed seven people before being executed in 1926 for the murder of James McCumber of Meigs County. Two young women savagely murdered and dumped. Mansfield denied involvement in the burglary and said he knew nothing about the stolen guitar, but he was arrested and charged with Theft By Possession. Davis was arrested in May in Hamilton County on a felony charge of promoting prostitution and is awaiting trial. In a June interview, Vicky Fible, Johnsons mother, expressed frustration about the lack of progress in her daughters case and said she hasnt communicated with Fairfield police in years. Co-defendant Timothy Mosley who stabbed Justin Back nearly two-dozen times while Myers watched avoided the death penalty by testifying against Myers. Submit a Crime Tip Square with arrow pointing upper right. It is this documentation that allows people like me to relay to others those dark segments of our local past that some may wish to keep buried away. In 1980, the FBI charged the then-Mahoning County sheriff of accepting bribes from mobsters. Detectives said Roush had more than 1,000 marijuana plants growing behind his rural home. Noting the pattern of the bullets and conditions of the bodies, according to police, it indicated that the killer was an excellent marksman.. Ence Day and thanksgiving. County officials were notified and an investigation was launched. (The US average is 35.4) NOTE: The city of Logan, Ohio does not have FBI Crime Statistics. She used arsenic to poison her husband shortly before he died Aug. 22, 1952 at their farm in Owensville. But then it disappeared, as had Herbert. An email message containing instructions on how to reset your password has been sent to the e-mail address listed on your account. Sister, aunt of East Liverpool triple homicide victims still - WKBN Reese spent 11 years in a state asylum before he died in 1966, according to the New York Daily News. The resident of Weirton, West Virginia, had died from blunt force trauma to the head. Its interesting that the officer who arrested Henderson would along with Hibbard Hatfield one year later be charged with a Dingess Street murder and later commit suicide during a break in his trial. Grate could face the death penalty if he is convicted. Dwight Williamson: Logan County history filled with unsolved murders It spurred a lot of debate, but we've come up with what we think is the most completelist of current and former Ohioans who are known for all the wrong reasons. 8 unsolved murders in the Miami Valley - WHIO TV 7 And WHIO Radio I knew the whole family, and the Schneider triple homicide is what set me on this path for truth and justice. Missing persons, signs of extra terrestrial life and thousands of anonymous, vindictive letters are just a few of the uncanny happenings in Ohio that have yet to be solved over the years in spite of ongoing investigations. Marvin Johnson is awaiting execution on Ohio's death row for the Aug. 15, 2003 rape and robbery of his ex-girlfriend and the murder of her son. And,. The Kirtland cult leader claimed God commanded him to kill the five members of the Avery family on April 17, 1989. That hole has been there since the murder of her sister, Linda Morris, 22, and niece, Angela Lynn, 4. A 40-year-old unsolved homicide is getting a new look from police, and a local mother hopes her efforts will bring in tips for other cold cases like it. It is the right thing to do. Although several friends and relatives of the victims were questioned concerning the shooting, no definite clues were ever discovered, and the deaths were never solved. Shane Roush has been sentenced to 25 years in prison for his role in a shootout that seriously injured a Morrow County Sheriff's deputy in 2010. James Worley is charged with murder in the death of college student Sierah Joughin, who was found in a shallow grave on July 22, 2016. Baumeister is also suspected of killing approximately 10 others and leaving their bodies along the Interstate 70 corridor to Columbus including in Darke and Preble counties. He then spent seven years in prison for taking bribes, racketeering and filing false tax returns. Canadian businessman Ollie Mastronardi served nearly four years in prison for the drunken boating accident that killed Scott Brabander in 1995. Logan County authorities are ignoring the new information, facts, and evidence Ive brought forth in the Martin and Schneider cases. The deaths took a heavy toll on their families as Baisden was survived by five daughters, two sons, one sister and three brothers. Theres no other way to put it the Indians were murdered. There's actors, businessmen, philanthropists, war heroes and industrialists, but there's another side, a seedier side that includes criminals, mass murderers, crooked politicians and cult leaders. There were/are manyanomalies in the Schneider case, too many to bring out in this writing, but Ill mention a few. In 2006, a German attorney filed a complaint accusing Miller of crimes against humanity, but he was never charged. Cepec became the first person to receive the death penalty in Medina County in 60 years, according to The Medina Gazette. Willie McCloud' page from the Unsolved Homicides Database. Other murders come to mind, such as the death of Susie Fortuna, Alex Sayer, Barlow Ramey, and others. But the state's history also includes notorious figures such as bank robber John Dillinger and Watergate cover-up artist John Dean. Create a password that only you will remember. The pair served time in juvenile detention centers and have since been released. The pair also shot six others during a drug-related robbery in Lima. Theres no doubt he was involved in the murders of Mansfield and Martin, but the facts and evidence in those cases support that he used accomplices. This Vault In Ohio Holds One Of The Worlds Most Closely-Guarded Secrets, The Adults-Only Resort In Ohio Where You Can Enjoy Some Much-Needed Peace And Quiet, This Enchanting And Historic Town In Ohio Is The Perfect Day Trip Destination, This Ohio Bakery Gives Donut Lovers The Chance To Design Their Very Own Custom Donut. My father, Logan County States Attorney Roger W. Thompson (1972-1980), alerted authorities the morning of Oct. 10th that Jay Fry and Ruth Martin were witnesses in the Kroger shoplifting case. Your account has been registered, and you are now logged in. Former superintendent Mike McVey had also been accused of misleading authorities investigating the case. Jacob Nesbitt strangled his wife on Feb. 11, 1926. His crimes occurred in Ohio and West Virginia. Former Canton police officer Bobby Lee Cutts killed his ex-girlfriend Jessie Davis and their unborn child in 2007. Seven members of Morans gang were killed in the St. Valentines Day Massacre of 1929 in Chicago. He disappeared, The same day Mansfield disappeared, the burglary matter was continued to March (unbeknownst to Mansfield and Smrekar) because the two female students whose dorm room had been burgled were still on their European vacation. Low 37F. beside of it, which became the unofficial name of the signal. She was alive, and her husband ran for help from friends who had just dropped him off from work. Scripps School of Journalism. Uncovered: Unsolved Murders By State He apparently didnt say what he did with Mansfield. Incident location: Lockbourne, Ohio - Franklin County . Oakwood resident Judith Hawkey was sentenced to life in prison for ordering her then-10-year-old stepson to shoot her husband in 2003. 2 Tug Valley sends Man packing in sectional semifinal, 70-28, Lincoln County man dies in crash near Chapmanville, Herd basketball trio takes home SBC honors, House passes religious freedoms bill after attempts to amend fail, WV Senate passes bill aimed at strengthening flood resiliency, 51 years later, memories still haunt survivors of Buffalo Creek flood, Chapmanville girls beat Liberty Raleigh, Mingo Central to win sectional title, Dwight Williamson: The truth hurts, as we learned 63 years ago, Outstanding cast makes Knights something special, Blevins resigns as Man mayor; Fekete appointed, Cline's charges referred to Grand Jury; bond reduction request denied, Dwight Williamson: Racism lived in Logan County in the 1950s, and still does, Amid heated exchange, Chapmanville council rescinds $2,000 sports donation. Randle Lee Roberts II shot and killed four family members, including an 11-year-old girl, in 2011 in West Union. Rick Jones was Judge Thorntons 21-year-old bailiffinthe courthouse the spring and summer of 76. He didnt have a vehicle, so he was on foot. His lies have demonstrated a clear intent to obstruct justice and cover-up critical information connected to vital blood evidence in an, A brutal triple homicide also occurred in the middle of all this. "She was an intelligent, attractive young woman. Uncovered: Unsolved Ohio Murders (NewsNation) The murder clearance rate hit an all-time low in 2020, and data analyzed by a nonprofit shows that trend continued last year. Your purchase was successful, and you are now logged in. [Unresolved Murder] Was Scott Moody framed for his family's - Reddit Steubenville High School football players Ma'lik Richmond and Trent Mays both 16 at the time were convicted in juvenile court for the Aug. 11, 2012 rape of a West Virginia girl. Map Browse By State. Following his arrest, information began to surface about another probable victim, Michael David Mansfield. Cleo Vernon Keaton was sentenced to death for the 1965 killing of a Williamsport man while he was fleeing charges related to the slaying of two men in a Dayton bar, according to a 1967 edition of The Ottumwa Courier. Community Rules apply to all content you upload or otherwise submit to this site. Sheriff's deputies called in the guardsmen to protect Mitchell from a mob outside the jail, according to The New York Times. Her body was found in a ditch days later, and investigators arrested Fox the next month. Investigators are still searching for the person or persons who killed eight members of the Rhoden family on April 22, 2016. Additional evidence collected with the white T-shirt linked to similar evidence inside the Martin Catalina in Bloomington. Two weeks later, on April 8, a state game warden looking to check the licenses of fishermen happened across Thompsons body on an embankment off the 260 block of East Kemper Road. Civil War general Robert Kingston Scott is best known for his tenure as South Carolinas governor and his sensational murder trial. Travis Lee Fischer was just 17 years old when he raped and killed a woman authorities described as being like a mother to him. The closest similar sized city with FBI crime data is the city . Map Browse By State. Investigators found the body of Heskett who disappeared on Valentine's Day in 2015 in a burn barrel on Ash's property. Name. A Franklin County jury convicted him of contributing to the delinquency of a minor, a misdemeanor, and he served nine days of a 30-day jail sentence. The elderly couple suffered from physical attacks, strange phone calls that were sometimes threatening and other times only heavy breathing and robbery. Mansfield, 19, was a somewhat shy, non-confrontational Lincoln College honor student from Rolling Meadows, IL. After Cincinnati police received a call saying Herman Brown had not been seen in a long time, officers were dispatched to the 46-year-old's apartment at 2572 Sarvis Court. Stewart had been reported missing four days earlier by her estranged husband and had no known ties to Columbiana County. Ruth Martins remains have never been found. Actually, though, it was not until The Logan Banner, then called the The Logan County Banner, came into existence in 1888 that news, including many murders, were documented in the form of newsprint. We didn't simply focus on convicted criminals (although the list has its share), instead we decided to focus on people who were noteworthy for nefarious reasons, but who were not necessarily found guilty of a crime. The history of Logan County is vast, and its longtime existence is marked by numerous tales of murder, beginning as far back as the 1700s when Aracoma and her tribe were attacked at what is now Midelburg Island in Logan. Cecil Dowell Age. She was partially clothed and had been beaten and strangled. For locals, the town of 1,300 is also known for its dark past. They are continuing to ignore the letters written by my fathers former assistants from 76, John Foltz and Pat Chesley, advising that reinvestigation of the Martin and Schneider cases is warranted and the right thing to do. Additionally, they are resisting my calls for official reinvestigation and DNA testing of evidence thats never been tested. The Lincoln PD said Smrekar admitted burying Martin under the new construction of I-55 (an area that can never be excavated), which was underway to replace Route 66 at the time of Ruths disappearance. Cold Cases Missing Persons Daily Archive. Hand claimed he shot Welch in self-defense after Welch broke into his house and shot his wife. Investigators looking into possible link between Stephenson murders and Litteral then relocated to Oregon, but investigators tracked him down and he confessed to the killing, according to a 1929 edition of The Athens Messenger. Georgia Rudolph of Macon, Georgia claims she is the reincarnated spirit of a Marietta woman named Sandra J. Jenkins, who commited suicide in 1911. Russ was a sociopath and a pathological liar who enjoyed leading people, especially police, on wildgoose chases. Whether this is a true example of reincarnation or not is unknown. For example, in 2002, former Logan County States Attorney Tim Huyett requested the handwritten Schneider crime lab report from the state crime lab archives; found on the clothes and under the Schneider victims fingernails were foreign fibers and two different colored foreign hairs that did not belong to them or Drabing. Dennis McGuire's 1989 rape and murder of Joy Stewart earned him a death sentence. He put on his buckskin coat and walked out the front door, leaving his wallet behind. The Lincoln PD regards the Martin case as closed because Smrekar allegedly confessed. Legendary coach Woody Hayes was fired for punching Clemson linebacker Charlie Bauman in the aftermath. 04-17-94. It wasnt until early September 76 that Logan County learned that Mansfield was officially a missing person and his family hadnt seen him since December 31st. These searches took additional time. One of the more recognizable murders in Logan that most people of today can identify with is that of young Mamie Thurman; her devilish murder occurring in 1932 and leaving many unanswered questions still today. Search Unsolved Homicide Victims Search Ohio homicide victims by name, city or keywords. Hensley later strangled a fellow prison inmate in 2002, according to the Associated Press. But it was taken away from her." After further investigation, including her passing lie detector tests, I cleared my name, she said. The writer was never revealed. All rights reserved (About Us). They found the 56-year-old dead inside in May 2005. 1976 Logan County murders and probable cover-up. McGuires family filed a federal lawsuit after he gasped and choked throughout the 24-minute process. Unsolved Homicides - Ohio Attorney General Dave Yost Each of the identified victims were suspected to be prostitutes, and each of those women were believed to work at truck stops. Ariel Castro's kidnapping of Michelle Knight, Amanda Berry and Gina DeJesus attracted international attention when the women escaped his Cleveland house in 2013. Hoffman hid their bodies inside a tree in the Kokosing Lake Wildlife Area, according to The Columbus Dispatch. As for Mansfield, there was very little evidence in his case, which has made his murder the toughest one to solve. He has been sentenced to life in prison. Please SIGN THE PETITIONon this websitecalling for official reinvestigation and DNA testing of all applicable existing evidence in the Mansfield, Martin, and Schneider murder cases. In light of Kruegers egregious lies and the importance of the details relating to the T-shirt, that evidence most assuredly did not disappear (if its really missing) by accident, and it also didnt sprout legs and walk out of the LPD on its own. Dillon was arrested on weapons charges in 1992 and later pleaded guilty to the murders to avoid the death penalty. Dean died two years later by electrocution, according to The Clermont Sun. Bloomingburg native and former Ohio State and NFL quarterback Art Schlichter is perhaps best known for throwing the decisive interception in the 1978 Gator Bowl.